Log in

No account? Create an account
10 November 2010 @ 03:56 pm
Willing To Die To Be Thin  
Here's an interesting post about The Biggest Loser. I love the cultural analysis and challenge to their practices on the basis of health. Rapid weight loss is not considered to be healthy and making fat people run until they literally drop could get someone killed someday. Too bad we couldn't have a less extreme and less dangerous, positive program that inspires people to change their lifestyle in healthy ways.

This article points to another article by The New York Times about the serious health risks of weight loss on the show, where contestants have admitted that they urinated blood. Don't do this at home! But of course, we fat people have done many dangerous things to fit in to our fat-hating, no, fat-vilifying, fat-bashing, fat-loathing culture. Sometimes I think that Americans would just like to march us into death camps or something and be done with us, especially when I read comments sections such as the one following the Southwest Airlines debacle with our beloved "Silent Bob."

As Tristin Aaron points out on the Media Health blog, now being fat is considered to be a civic problem: "What was once a personal struggle to eat well has acquired new civic and moral weight." Most people always thought that other people's weight was their business, but never more than they do now. We are taking dollars right out of their pocket by driving up health care! We are bad for the environment! We are eating their food! (I actually saw the last in a comment, as if in America most people are starving because the fat people emptied the supermarket.)

The New York Times article was chilling. Apparently what happens in The Biggest Loser stays there. Like Vegas or Fight Club, no one is supposed to reveal the lengths people go to, the nature of the waiver they sign, the dangerous practices, or the quick regain from finally drinking enough water--up to 30 lbs. That's severe dehydration--no wonder people are urinating blood.

The NYT writes: "Getting contestants to talk openly about the environment of the program is difficult. Shortly after a reporter started contacting former contestants to interview them about their experiences, a talent producer on the series sent an e-mail message to many former contestants reminding them that 'serious consequences' could ensue if they ever talked to a reporter without the show’s permission. " Wow, do they send someone to the former contestant's house? No, apparently there are hefty fines from 100K to a million dollars, depending on how long it's been since the show they were in first aired. That's quite an incentive not to talk frankly. (I'm betting they don't fine you for saying only nice things about the show.)

Contestants also have to sign a statement that they think they are "in excellent physical, emotional, psychological and mental health." It's interesting that The Biggest Loser is admitting contestants over 400 pounds yet the show agrees that you can be that weight and be in excellent health. Why do you need to lose weight, then? Supposedly you are losing weight for your health, but as a society we are told no fat people can be healthy. If we aren't healthy, we have no business putting our bodies under such serious stress for rapid weight loss which is known to be dangerous and can lead to heart attacks and sudden cardiac arrest. What a conflict! One that the show sidesteps by having contestants sign that useless statement. They aren't medical professionals. They are fat people desperate to fit in, be loved, and make some money--and being exploited for ratings.

In the many years I've lived as a fat person in this country, I've seen a lot of weight loss scams, many of them extremely dangerous. But I think The Biggest Loser is at the top of the list when it comes to outright exploitation and physical danger. Even Dr. Stillman's Quick Weight Loss Diet didn't have me urinating blood. (The core of the diet back in the late 60s was eating only two foods a day. Subsequent versions were low carb/high protein. It was under his literary influence that I went on 200-500 calorie a day diets. My two foods were 1 egg plus 1 piece of toast.)

I just hope that The Biggest Loser doesn't kill anyone. But don't worry--they have a waiver.
(Deleted comment)
Tapatitapati on November 11th, 2010 04:26 pm (UTC)

Me too. I've probably only watched a few minutes of it, ever, but I hate the whole premise and their methodology with a passion.
W. Lotus: Gen Displeasedwlotus on November 11th, 2010 02:27 am (UTC)
I'm surprised The Biggest Loser hasn't already killed someone. That show makes me very angry.
Tapatitapati on November 11th, 2010 04:27 pm (UTC)

Guardian angels working overtime? Really, it is amazing that they haven't killed or disabled someone.
Phatchick: stupidityladybrigid on November 11th, 2010 04:19 pm (UTC)
I've probably lost the equivalent of my body weight at least 3 times over in my lifetime. I finally quit when I hit my 30s and realilzed I was never going to look like Kate Moss. I've come to the conclusion that the people who love me, love me for who and what I am and the people who don't like me fat would hate me thin.
I'd like to put the producers of that idiotic show on treadmills and have them all run until they lose 80 lbs each or pee blood, whichever comes first. Jerks.
Tapatitapati on November 11th, 2010 04:30 pm (UTC)

They are petty vile, and I hate that the whole show is cloaked in this guise of helping fat people.

I have achieved healthy weight loss (after years of crash diets) and kept it off for a few years, gained back slowly, and they could choose to teach the contestants the skills to do that and follow their journey as they do, instead of this horrid lose fastest competition. But I guess that wouldn't bring in the large audience they get for this show.

I never achieved Kate Moss thinness either, even when I starved myself. I only ever got to within 25 pounds of the "ideal" weight those charts touted.